When Should I Use Combing in 3D Printing?

Navigating the world of 3D printing can be a maze of challenges, from battling stringing issues to achieving the perfect surface finish. It’s a journey I’ve been on, and trust me, it’s both thrilling and daunting.

Enter the game-changer: combing mode in 3D printing. This nifty feature, often overlooked, can be a real lifesaver. In this post, we’re diving into the depths of combing – what it is, how it works, and most importantly, answering the burning question: When should I use combing in 3D printing?

Whether you’re a seasoned pro or just starting, understanding combing can elevate your 3D printing game to new heights. Let’s unravel the mystery together!

Read More:

• How to Fix a Clicking Extruder on a 3D Printer? (5 min read)
• How to Fix Z Banding on a 3D Printer? (A Comprehensive Guide) (6 min read)
• How to Level Your 3D Printer Bed with Nozzle Height Calibration? (5 min read)
• How to Remove Broken Filament From Your 3D Printer? (7 min read)

Understanding Combing in 3D Printing

What Exactly is Combing Mode?

Ever had those annoying stringy bits ruining your 3D print? That’s where combing mode steps in. Think of it as a clever navigator for your printer’s nozzle.

Instead of taking the shortest path between points, which often crosses open air and leaves those pesky strings, combing mode guides the nozzle to move within the already printed areas. It’s like telling your nozzle, “Hey, stick to the roads, not the shortcuts!”

Combing in Action

Now, how does this magic happen in slicer software like Cura and PrusaSlicer? It’s pretty straightforward. When you toggle on combing mode in these programs, you’re essentially programming the printer’s brain.

It starts to calculate paths that avoid crossing the empty space. Imagine it as a GPS rerouting to avoid traffic, ensuring the nozzle stays within the confines of your print, reducing the need for retractions, and keeping those strings at bay.

Combing (right) directs the printhead to move within the interior of a print, as opposed to the exterior (left). Source: UltiMaker Support

The Impact on Print Quality

The role of combing in elevating print quality is undeniable. By minimizing the travel over open spaces, it drastically cuts down on stringing. This means smoother surfaces and cleaner prints.

Plus, it’s not just about looks; combing also contributes to the structural integrity of your print by maintaining consistent material flow. It’s like having an expert craftsman smoothing out the edges, ensuring your masterpiece comes out just the way you envisioned.

The Different Combing Modes in Cura

In the world of 3D printing, combing modes in Cura are like different flavors of ice cream – each has its unique taste and purpose. Let’s dive into these modes and see how they can change the game for your prints.

1. Not in Skin

Starting with ‘Not in Skin,’ this mode is your go-to for most standard prints. It’s like having a careful driver who avoids the main roads (the outer walls of your print) to prevent any visible marks. This mode is perfect when you’re aiming for a smooth, blemish-free outer surface. It’s particularly handy for models where the exterior finish is the star of the show.

“Not in Skin” prevents combing in the bottom (above) and top layers. (Source: All3DP)

2. Within Infill

Next up, ‘Within Infill.’ Think of this as the cautious navigator, taking paths only within the less visible infill areas of your print. It’s a bit more restrictive, ensuring the nozzle doesn’t wander over any walls or skins. This mode is ideal for prints where internal strength is key, and you can afford a little extra print time for that added reliability.

3. Not on Outer Surface

Then we have ‘Not on Outer Surface.’ It’s a bit like ‘Not in Skin,’ but with a twist. Here, the nozzle avoids the outermost layer of your print, reducing the risk of any scars or blemishes on those critical outer surfaces. It’s a great choice for intricate designs where every detail on the surface counts.

4. All

The ‘All’ mode is your all-rounder. It combines the strategies of ‘Not in Skin’ and ‘Within Infill,’ keeping the nozzle movements within the print as much as possible. This mode is your best bet for complex geometries or when you’re looking to minimize stringing across the board.

The dark blue lines show the path of the nozzle with activated combing (Source: All3DP)

5. Off

Lastly, ‘Off’ is exactly what it sounds like – combing is completely disabled. This mode is for the times when you want to go back to basics, typically when troubleshooting or when you’ve got other settings dialed in so well that combing isn’t needed. It’s like driving with no GPS – sometimes, you just know the route well enough.

6. Comparing the Modes

Each combing mode has its place, depending on what you’re printing. ‘Not in Skin’ and ‘Not on Outer Surface’ are your aesthetic champions, ‘Within Infill’ is for when strength matters most, ‘All’ is the jack-of-all-trades for complex prints, and ‘Off’ is for when you’re confident in your printer’s pathfinding or troubleshooting.

It’s all about matching the mode to your project’s needs. For instance, if you’re printing a detailed figurine, ‘Not on Outer Surface’ might be your best bet to preserve those fine details. On the other hand, if you’re printing a sturdy mechanical part, ‘Within Infill’ could be the way to go for its internal strength.

Deciding When to Use

1. Navigating the Maze of Complex Geometries

Let’s start with the intricate stuff. You know those models with twists, turns, and overhangs that look like a 3D labyrinth? That’s where combing becomes your best friend. When you’re dealing with complex geometries, combing ensures that the nozzle moves smartly, avoiding unnecessary travel over open spaces.

This careful maneuvering is crucial for maintaining the integrity of those detailed areas, preventing stringing that could otherwise turn your intricate design into a cobwebby mess.

2. Aiming for High Surface Quality

Now, imagine you’re printing something where the surface finish is everything – like a showpiece or a prototype that needs to impress. Combing steps in as your quality controller.

By guiding the nozzle to travel within the confines of the print, it significantly reduces the risk of blemishes on the surface. It’s like having a skilled artisan ensuring every inch of the surface is flawless.

3. Projects with Extensive Infill Patterns

When you’re working on a project that’s more about strength than looks, like functional parts or mechanical components, combing in the ‘Within Infill’ mode is your go-to.

It keeps the nozzle movements within the infill, reinforcing the internal structure and ensuring the outer walls remain untouched and strong.

4. Material Considerations

Different materials behave differently. For instance, with string-prone materials like PETG or TPU, combing can be a game-changer. It helps manage those pesky strings and oozing, ensuring a cleaner print.

But remember, not all materials need the same level of babysitting. Sometimes, with well-tuned settings, you might not need combing at all.

5. Juggling Print Quality and Time

Here’s the deal – combing can add to your print time. It’s a trade-off. You get better quality, but it might take longer. So, it’s about finding that sweet spot.

For quick, less critical prints, you might skip combing. But for those prints where every detail counts, investing that extra time is worth it.

The Perks of Combing Mode in 3D Printing

1. Tackling Stringing and Oozing

Picture this: you’ve spent hours on a print, only to find it looking like a spider’s web at the end. Frustrating, right? That’s where combing mode steps in as a hero.

By keeping the nozzle’s travel within the printed areas, it drastically cuts down on those annoying strings and blobs of oozing filament. It’s like having a meticulous cleaner who tidies up as they go, ensuring that your print comes out neat and clean.

2. Achieving a Smoother Surface Finish

Now, let’s talk about looks. We all want prints that are smooth to the touch and pleasing to the eye. Combing mode contributes significantly to this by reducing the scars and blemishes that can occur during travel moves.

It’s akin to an artist carefully smoothing out the brush strokes on a canvas, resulting in a masterpiece that’s smooth and detailed.

3. Saving Time on Certain Prints

Here’s an interesting twist: while combing mode can add time to complex prints, it can actually speed up simpler projects. By reducing the number of retractions needed, it streamlines the printing process.

This means for certain prints, especially those with less intricate details, you can actually see a decrease in overall print time. It’s like finding a shortcut on a familiar route that shaves off a few minutes from your journey.

Navigating the Downsides of Combing in 3D Printing

1. The Time Factor in Complex Prints

Let’s face it, we all value our time, and in 3D printing, time is often of the essence. While combing mode can be a lifesaver in many scenarios, it’s not without its trade-offs.

For models with complex geometries or extensive travel paths, combing can actually lead to longer print times. It’s like taking a scenic route on a road trip; sure, the views are great, but it takes longer to reach your destination.

In 3D printing, this means the nozzle takes more time navigating around the print, carefully avoiding open spaces, which adds up over the course of the print.

2.Scarring

Then there’s the issue of scarring, especially on the top layers of your print. Imagine you’ve almost finished a perfect print, but then you notice those slight imperfections on the surface, like tiny trails or marks where the nozzle passed over.

It’s a bit like a meticulous gardener who keeps the lawn pristine but accidentally steps on the flower beds. Combing mode, in its effort to reduce stringing, can sometimes leave these small but noticeable marks on the top layers of your print.

3. Movement Limitations

Lastly, let’s talk about the limitations in movement paths. Combing mode restricts the nozzle’s path to within the printed areas, which, while reducing stringing, can also limit the efficiency of the print head movements.

It’s akin to being on a strict path in a maze; you avoid the pitfalls, but sometimes it’s not the most direct route. This limitation can be particularly noticeable in prints where unrestricted movement would have been more efficient.

Combing Mode Across Different Slicing Software

Diving into the world of 3D printing software is like exploring a city full of diverse neighborhoods. Each slicer, be it Cura, PrusaSlicer, or others, has its own unique way of handling combing.

It’s fascinating to see how each software interprets and implements this feature, much like chefs tweaking a classic recipe to suit their style.

Cura vs. PrusaSlicer

Cura, for instance, is like the Swiss Army knife of slicers when it comes to combing. It offers a range of modes, each tailored for specific needs, giving you the flexibility to tweak your prints to perfection. On the other hand, PrusaSlicer approaches combing a bit differently.

It might not label its settings as ‘combing,’ but it offers similar functionalities, focusing more on the efficiency of travel moves. It’s like comparing two skilled painters, each with their own brush strokes and techniques.

Customizing Your Path

The real magic, however, lies in customization. Both Cura and PrusaSlicer, along with other slicers, allow you to tweak and fine-tune the combing paths.

This customization is akin to a GPS system that you can program to avoid highways or take scenic routes, depending on what you prefer for your journey. It’s about making the software work for you, adapting its combing strategies to suit the specific needs of your print.

Mastering Combing Settings for Superior 3D Prints

In the realm of 3D printing, tweaking combing settings is akin to a musician fine-tuning their instrument for the perfect sound. It’s a delicate balance, one that can elevate your prints from good to exceptional.

1. The Art of Balancing Settings

Imagine you’re a juggler, with each ball representing a different print setting. Combing is one of those balls, and keeping it in harmony with the others is key.

It’s not just about cranking it up to the max; it’s about understanding how it interacts with print speed, layer height, and retraction settings. Like in a well-orchestrated symphony, each element needs to be in sync for the best performance.

2. Tailoring to Materials and Resolutions

Each material sings its own tune. PLA might be forgiving and easy to work with, but TPU can be a diva, demanding specific settings for optimal performance. Adjusting combing settings for different materials is like changing your approach based on the audience you’re performing for.

Similarly, print resolution adds another layer to this. High-resolution prints require a more nuanced approach to combing, ensuring that every fine detail is captured without being marred by unnecessary stringing or oozing.

3. The Power of Experimentation

Now, let’s talk about experimentation. It’s like being a chef in a kitchen, trying out different recipes until you find the perfect one. Change one setting at a time, observe the results, and take notes.

What works for one print might not work for another. It’s a process of discovery, where each test brings you closer to understanding the ideal combing settings for your specific printer and project.

Remember, there’s no one-size-fits-all in 3D printing. Each printer, filament, and model is unique, and finding the perfect combing settings is part of the journey.

Embrace this process of trial and error. It’s through these experiments that you’ll unlock the full potential of your 3D printer, achieving prints that not only look great but are structurally sound. So, dive in, tweak, test, and watch as your 3D printing skills reach new heights of precision and quality.

Conclusion

As we reach the end of our exploration into combing in 3D printing, it’s clear that this feature is more than just a setting; it’s a tool for precision and quality.

We’ve seen how it can transform prints with complex geometries, enhance surface finishes, and sometimes even speed up the process. Remember, the key lies in understanding your project’s needs and experimenting with different settings.

Don’t be afraid to tinker and test; every print offers a new learning opportunity. Embrace the trial and error process – it’s through these experiments that you’ll discover the optimal combing settings for your unique prints.

In the world of 3D printing, combing isn’t just a technique; it’s an art form, one that you get better at with each print. So, keep exploring, keep refining, and watch as your prints reach new heights of perfection.