How To Prevent Pillowing in 3D Prints (3 Simple Steps)

Date:

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Pillowing is comparable to an unexpected visitor arriving right when you’re about to revel in a flawless print. It refers to the annoying bulges and voids on the top surface of your print, transforming what could be a work of art into a disorderly creation.

Trust me, I’ve been there, staring at a print that was almost perfect, wondering where I went wrong. That’s why understanding how to prevent pillowing in 3D printing is crucial.

It’s not just about making your prints look good; it’s about ensuring they’re top-notch in quality.
Let’s address this directly, ensuring your upcoming print matches the perfection you’ve imagined.

Read More:

What is Pillowing in 3D Printing?

rtaImage?eid=ka05b000000XwCv&feoid=00N5b00000DhP2e&refid=0EM5b000009BWkV | 3D Gear Guide

Pillowing in 3D printing is when the top layer of your print ends up with bumps and gaps, ruining the smooth finish you expected. It can be quite disheartening, especially following hours of printing, to observe your end product appearing coarse and irregular.

This issue often happens when the top layer doesn’t stick well enough to the layers beneath it. My first experience with pillowing was a real headache; I had hoped for a perfectly smooth surface but ended up with something that looked more like a lumpy bedspread.

It’s a common problem, especially if you’re new to 3D printing, but it’s definitely something you can fix with the right know-how. Let’s see what causes this and how to avoid it in your future projects.

Primary Causes of Pillowing

Pillowing in 3D printing can be a real headache, and it’s usually down to a few key factors.

1. Inadequate cooling and its impact

| 3D Gear Guide

When your print doesn’t cool evenly or quickly enough, it leads to those annoying bumps on the top layer.

2. Insufficient First layer thickness

Not having a thick enough top layer can cause this issue. If it’s too thin, it won’t cover the gaps properly, leading to pillowing.

You can also watch this video for clear concept,

3. Low infill density and its consequences

IMG 2071 | 3D Gear Guide

Another big factor is low infill density. When the infill isn’t dense enough, it doesn’t support the top layer as it should, causing it to sag and create those pillowy effects.

4. High print speed and temperature settings

Lastly, high print speed and temperature settings can also contribute. If you print too fast or too hot, it can prevent proper adhesion and cooling, leading to—you guessed it—pillowing.

Each of these factors plays a role, and getting them right can be the difference between a smooth finish and a bumpy mess.

How To Fix Pillowing in 3D Prints?

A. Optimizing Print Settings

  1. Adjusting Layer Height:

Adjusting the layer height is a crucial step in tackling pillowing. A thinner layer height can lead to finer details but may increase the risk of pillowing due to less material supporting the top layer.

On the flip side, a thicker layer height provides more stability but can compromise on detail. Finding a balance is key.

For most of my prints, setting the layer height to around 0.2mm worked well, offering a good mix of detail and stability.

2. Balancing Print Speed and Quality:

The speed at which your printer operates can significantly impact the occurrence of pillowing. Printing too fast might not give layers enough time to cool and bond properly, leading to pillowing.

However, printing too slowly can also have its drawbacks, like longer print times and potential issues with filament flow. I’ve found that a moderate print speed, not too fast nor too slow, often yields the best results.

It’s about finding that sweet spot where your printer can lay down layers efficiently without compromising the cooling and bonding process.

3. Setting Optimal Printing Temperatures:

Temperature settings play a pivotal role in print quality. Too hot, and your filament won’t cool quickly enough, leading to pillowing. Too cold, and you might face adhesion problems.

Each filament type has its ideal temperature range, and it’s worth experimenting within this range to find what works best for your specific printer and filament.

For instance, with PLA, I usually start around 200°C and adjust based on the print’s appearance and performance. Remember, even small adjustments can make a big difference in preventing pillowing.

For more detailed insights on temperature variations and their impact on 3D printing quality, read this comprehensive guide.

If you’re an Ultimaker 2 user, then watch this quick video to learn how you can prevent pillowing in your 3d prints.

B. Enhancing Cooling Efficiency

  1. Utilizing Cooling Fans Effectively:

Cooling fans are your first line of defense against pillowing. They help to rapidly cool down each layer as it’s printed, preventing the top layer from warping and forming those unwanted bumps.

I learned the hard way that not all cooling fans are created equal. Upgrading to a more powerful fan made a noticeable difference in my prints.

It’s also crucial to ensure that your fan is always clean and unobstructed. Even a small amount of dust can reduce its effectiveness, leading to pillowing.

2. Positioning and Adjusting Fan Speed:

The position and speed of your cooling fan can make or break a print. Initially, I had my fan set to blow directly on the nozzle, which seemed logical, but it actually led to uneven cooling.

After some trial and error, I found that positioning the fan to evenly cool the entire print surface worked best. Adjusting the fan speed is also key.

For materials like PLA, a higher fan speed is beneficial, but for ABS, too much cooling can cause its own problems. It’s all about finding the right balance for the material you’re using and the specific model you’re printing.

C. Infill Considerations

  1. Choosing the Right Infill Density:

    Infill density is a game-changer in preventing pillowing. It’s all about providing enough support for the top layers of your print. Too little infill, and you risk the top layer sagging into those gaps, leading to pillowing.

    But, crank up the infill too high, and you’re wasting material and time. I’ve found that an infill density of around 20-25% strikes a good balance for most prints. It’s enough to support the top layer without being overkill.

    Remember, the right infill density can vary depending on the size and complexity of your print.
  2. Selecting Appropriate Infill Patterns:

    The pattern of your infill also plays a crucial role. Some patterns offer more support than others.

    For instance, a grid pattern provides a good balance of strength and material usage, making it a solid choice for many prints.

    However, for objects that need more strength, a honeycomb pattern might be better, though it uses more filament. It’s about matching the pattern to the needs of your print.

    A trial-and-error approach works well here. Experiment with different patterns and see how they affect the finish of your top layer. The right pattern can make all the difference in smoothing out those top layers.

How To Fix Mild Pillowing? (Quick Fixes)

If you’re facing mild pillowing in your 3D prints, this usually means the issue isn’t deeply rooted in your printing process.

Start by slightly increasing the top layer thickness in your slicer settings. This extra layer can often compensate for minor imperfections, smoothing out those small bumps.

Additionally, tweaking the cooling fan speed can help. If it’s too low, bump it up a bit to ensure better cooling of the top layers. These small adjustments are often enough to resolve mild pillowing without needing to overhaul your entire printing setup.

Remember, sometimes a little tweak is all it takes to turn a good print into a great one.

How To Get a Smooth Top Layer and Avoid Pillowing

A. Slicer Software Adjustments

  1. Tweaking Overlap Percentages:

    Getting the overlap percentages right in your slicer software can be a game-changer. It’s about how much the infill overlaps with the outer walls.

    Too little overlap, and you’ll have weak spots prone to pillowing. Too much, and you might end up with a messy, over-extruded print. I’ve found that increasing the overlap percentage slightly from the default setting often helps.

    It strengthens the bond between the infill and the outer layers, reducing the chances of pillowing. It’s a
    delicate balance, but a few tweaks here and there can make a significant difference.
  2. Customizing Top Layer Settings:

    The top layer settings in your slicer software are crucial for a smooth finish. If it’s too thin, you’ll likely see pillowing. I usually increase the number of top layers in the slicer settings. This extra thickness acts as a barrier, preventing the infill pattern from showing through and causing pillowing.

    It’s also worth experimenting with different top layer patterns. Some patterns might work better for certain prints, giving you that smooth, professional finish you’re after.
  3. Utilizing Advanced Slicer Features:

    Modern slicer software comes packed with advanced features that can help combat pillowing. Features like ironing, where the printer goes over the top layer again to smooth it out, can be incredibly effective.

    It’s like using a mini iron to flatten out all those tiny imperfections. Another useful feature is the gradual infill step, which increases infill density towards the top layers. This provides more support where it’s needed most, helping to prevent pillowing.

    These advanced features might seem daunting at first, but they’re worth exploring. They can take your prints from good to great, eliminating pillowing and giving you that perfect finish.

B. Filament Selection and Its Role in Pillowing

  1. Comparing Different Filament Types:

    Choosing the right filament is crucial in avoiding pillowing. Different materials behave differently under the same printing conditions.

    For example, PLA is generally more forgiving and less prone to pillowing compared to ABS, which requires precise temperature control to avoid issues.

    I’ve noticed that flexible filaments like TPU can be tricky; they often need fine-tuned settings to get a smooth top layer. Each filament type has its quirks, and understanding these can help you anticipate and prevent pillowing.

2. Recommendations for Filament Choices:

When it comes to selecting filaments to reduce pillowing, start with something user-friendly like PLA. It’s great for beginners and less likely to pillow under standard printing conditions.

If you’re working with ABS or other high-temperature materials, ensure your printer is well-ventilated and the temperature is consistently controlled. For those experimenting with flexible filaments, patience is key. They might require slower print speeds and higher infill densities to combat pillowing.

The filament you choose can make a big difference in the quality of your final print, so choose wisely based on your project’s needs and your printer’s capabilities.

C. Printer Maintenance and Pillowing

  1. Importance of Regular Printer Maintenance:

    Regular maintenance of your 3D printer is crucial in preventing pillowing. It’s like taking care of a car; routine check-ups can prevent bigger issues down the road.

    Keeping the printer clean and well-lubricated ensures that all parts move smoothly. This is especially important for the moving parts like the print bed and extruder.

    A well-maintained printer maintains consistent quality in prints, reducing the chances of pillowing. I learned this the hard way when neglecting regular maintenance led to inconsistent print quality and, eventually, pillowing.
  2. Identifying Wear and Tear That Contributes to Pillowing:

    Wear and tear on your printer can sneak up on you and is a common culprit behind pillowing. For instance, a worn-out nozzle can affect the precision of your extrusion, leading to uneven layers that are prone to pillowing.

    Belts and pulleys that have seen better days can result in misaligned layers, another contributor to pillowing. Regularly inspecting these components and replacing them when necessary can save you a lot of headaches.

    It’s all about being proactive with your maintenance; catching these issues early can make a significant difference in the quality of your prints.

Advanced Techniques and Tips

  1. Implementing Ironing for Smoother Top Layers:

    Ironing is a slicer feature that can significantly improve the smoothness of your top layers, helping to prevent pillowing.

    It works by moving the hot nozzle over the top layer without extruding any filament, essentially ‘ironing’ out any imperfections.

    This technique has been a game-changer for me, especially for prints where the aesthetic of the top layer is crucial. It’s like giving your print a final polish, ensuring a smooth and even surface.
  2. Adjusting Z-Offset for Better Top Layer Adhesion:

    Adjusting the Z-offset is another effective way to combat pillowing. This involves changing the initial height of your print nozzle above the build plate.

    By fine-tuning this setting, you can improve the first layer’s adhesion, which sets the foundation for the rest of your print.

    A well-adhered first layer means less warping and, consequently, less pillowing. It’s a subtle adjustment, but it can make a significant difference in the quality of your prints.
  3. Experimenting with Larger Diameter Filaments:

    Using larger diameter filaments, like 2.85mm instead of the standard 1.75mm, can also help in preventing pillowing. These larger filaments offer more stability and are less prone to cooling down too quickly, which is a common cause of pillowing.

    While it might require some adjustments to your printer settings, experimenting with these larger filaments can lead to a noticeable improvement in the quality of your top layers, especially in larger prints where pillowing is more prevalent.

Each of these advanced techniques offers a unique approach to how to prevent pillowing in 3D printing. While they might require some experimentation and fine-tuning, they can significantly enhance the quality of your prints, giving you that flawless finish you’re aiming for.

Case Studies Demonstrating Effective Pillowing Prevention
(Before and After Scenarios
)

Case Study 1: The PLA Puzzle

Before: A user was printing a large, flat PLA piece. Despite a seemingly perfect setup, the top layer finished with noticeable pillowing, leaving a bumpy and uneven surface.

After: By adjusting the cooling fan speed and increasing the top layer thickness, the user saw a dramatic improvement. The top layer came out smooth and even, with no signs of pillowing. The key change was the enhanced cooling, which allowed the PLA to settle evenly without warping.

Case Study 2: ABS Adventure

Before: Printing with ABS, another user faced severe pillowing issues. The top layer of their prints was consistently rough, with gaps and bumps.

After: The solution involved a combination of reducing print speed and increasing infill density. Slower printing allowed the ABS to cool more uniformly, while the higher infill provided better support for the top layer. The result was a smooth, pillowing-free finish.

Case Study 3: TPU Trials

Before: A user experimenting with TPU filament struggled with pillowing, primarily due to the filament’s flexibility.

After: The breakthrough came with tweaking the Z-offset and implementing ironing in the slicer settings. These adjustments ensured better adhesion of the initial layers and a smoother finish on the top layer. The final print was significantly improved, with a uniform and pillowing-free surface.

These case studies demonstrate that various factors contribute to pillowing, and the solutions often require a tailored approach depending on the filament type and print specifics. Regular maintenance, appropriate slicer settings, and understanding the unique properties of different filaments are key to achieving high-quality, pillowing-free prints.

Conclusion

In our journey to tackle pillowing in 3D printing, we’ve uncovered that the key lies in a blend of precise settings, regular maintenance, and a deep understanding of our materials and equipment.

From tweaking slicer settings like layer height and infill density to ensuring our cooling systems are up to par, each step plays a pivotal role in achieving that flawless finish. The journey doesn’t end here, though. The field of 3D printing is ever-evolving, and with it, our learning curve.

Continuous experimentation and adaptation are vital. Each print offers a new opportunity to refine our techniques and push the boundaries of what we can achieve. So, keep experimenting, keep learning, and let’s keep pushing the limits of our 3D printing adventures.

Share post:

Popular

More like this
Related

How to Change Filament During Print?

3D printing, a realm where creativity meets technology, has...

How to Copy a Key with a 3D Printer?

3D printing technology has revolutionized how we create and...

How to 3D Print Something Without a 3D Printer

3D printing, a marvel of modern technology, has transformed...

How to Assemble a 3D Printer (Ender 3 V2 Example)

Embarking on the journey of assembling the Ender 3...

By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. more information

The cookie settings on this website are set to "allow cookies" to give you the best browsing experience possible. If you continue to use this website without changing your cookie settings or you click "Accept" below then you are consenting to this.

Close